Table of Contents
- Overcontributing to an RRSP and the Adverse Tax Implications
- Example of Overcontributions to an RRSP
- Where to Find Information on RRSP Overcontributions
Overcontributing to an RRSP and the Adverse Tax Implications
While undeducted RRSP contributions can be a useful tax planning tool, overcontributing to an RRSP is a situation that can lead to penalties and should be carefully avoided. Understanding the difference between these two concepts is essential for anyone preparing taxes or advising clients on RRSP planning.
What Is an Overcontribution?
An overcontribution occurs when someone contributes more to their RRSP than their available contribution room allows. The RRSP contribution room is determined based on:
- The RRSP limit reported on the individual’s Notice of Assessment
- Contributions carried forward from previous years
Exceeding this limit can trigger a penalty tax, unlike undeducted contributions, which are simply contributions left unused for future deduction.
Example:
- Amanda’s RRSP contribution limit for the year is $15,000.
- If she contributes $19,000, she has overcontributed by $4,000.
- She can deduct only $15,000 on her tax return, and the remaining $4,000 may be subject to penalties.
The Allowable Overcontribution Buffer
The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) recognizes that small errors can occur, so there is an overcontribution buffer of $2,000. This means:
- Overcontributions up to $2,000 are allowed without penalty.
- Any amount over this $2,000 buffer is subject to a 1% per month penalty.
Example:
- Using Amanda again: her RRSP limit is $15,000.
- She contributes $17,000. This is $2,000 over her limit, which is allowed—no penalty applies.
- If she contributes $18,000, $1,000 of that is subject to 1% per month penalty tax until corrected.
How the Penalty Works
- The penalty is 1% per month on the excess amount above the $2,000 buffer.
- This means that over time, the penalty can add up to 12% per year if the overcontributed amount is not addressed.
- The penalty continues until the overcontributed amount is either:
- Withdrawn from the RRSP, or
- Deducted in a future year once contribution room becomes available
Key Points for Tax Preparers
- Always check contribution limits – Review the client’s most recent Notice of Assessment to determine exact RRSP limits.
- Distinguish overcontributions from undeducted contributions – Undeducted contributions are fine and can be carried forward; overcontributions above the $2,000 buffer are penalized.
- Advise timely action – If a client has overcontributed, removing the excess as soon as possible avoids ongoing penalty charges.
- Educate clients – Many taxpayers are unaware of the penalty rules, so explaining the $2,000 buffer and monthly 1% charge is important.
Summary
Overcontributions can be costly, so they should always be monitored closely. While undeducted contributions are a tool for tax planning, exceeding the RRSP limit by more than $2,000 triggers penalties and additional administrative steps. As a tax preparer, your role is to help clients stay within their contribution limits, make the most of their RRSP deductions, and avoid unnecessary CRA penalties.
Example of Overcontributions to an RRSP
To understand the concept of overcontributing to an RRSP, it’s helpful to look at a practical example. This will clarify how overcontributions occur and what the tax consequences can be.
Meet Andrew
Andrew has an RRSP contribution limit for the year of $8,000, as reported on his most recent Notice of Assessment from the CRA. This limit represents the maximum amount he can contribute to his RRSP for the year without triggering a penalty.
During the year, Andrew made the following contributions:
- $6,500 during the year
- $7,000 in the first 60 days of the following year
Altogether, his contributions add up to $13,500.
Calculating the Overcontribution
Andrew’s RRSP limit is $8,000. Subtracting this from his total contributions gives:
13,500 − 8,000 = 5,500
This means Andrew has overcontributed by $5,500.
However, the CRA allows a small buffer for overcontributions:
- $2,000 is allowed without penalty
- Amounts above $2,000 are subject to a 1% per month penalty
In Andrew’s case:
- Allowed overcontribution: $2,000
- Amount subject to penalty: 5,500 − 2,000 = $3,500
If these contributions remain in the RRSP without adjustment, Andrew would owe 1% per month on the $3,500 until he withdraws it or has enough new contribution room to deduct it.
The Special Rule for First 60-Day Contributions
Contributions made in the first 60 days of the following year can be applied to either the previous year or the current year.
- Andrew contributed $7,000 in the first 60 days of the next year.
- He can choose to deduct this $7,000 on his previous year’s tax return or his current year’s return.
- Because this $7,000 is larger than the $5,500 overcontribution, he can safely apply it to the following year without triggering a penalty.
If all of Andrew’s contributions had been made during the year, the $5,500 overcontribution would have incurred penalty tax.
Options to Resolve Overcontributions
When dealing with overcontributions, there are a few ways to resolve the situation:
- Withdraw the excess – Removing the amount over the allowed $2,000 buffer immediately stops the penalty from accumulating.
- Apply it in the following year – If new RRSP contribution room becomes available at the start of the next year, the excess can be deducted without penalty.
- Plan carefully with the client – Ensure that future contributions do not repeat the overcontribution scenario.
Key Takeaways
- Overcontributions happen when someone contributes more than their RRSP limit.
- There is a $2,000 buffer allowed without penalty; anything above is taxed at 1% per month.
- Contributions made in the first 60 days of the following year offer flexibility for deduction.
- As a tax preparer, it is crucial to review the client’s Notice of Assessment to determine the exact contribution limit and avoid penalties.
Understanding this example helps you distinguish between undeducted contributions (good tax planning) and overcontributions (potentially costly), which is a critical skill for anyone starting in Canadian tax preparation.
Where to Find Information on RRSP Overcontributions
When working with clients on RRSPs, one of the key tasks as a tax preparer is to identify if a client has overcontributed. Overcontributions can result in penalties if they exceed the allowed buffer, so knowing where to find this information is critical.
Sources of Information
The main source for RRSP contribution details, including overcontributions, is the client’s Notice of Assessment from the CRA. This document provides a complete summary of the client’s RRSP situation, including:
- RRSP Deduction Limit – This is the maximum amount the client can contribute to their RRSP for the tax year without penalties.
- Undeducted Contributions – Contributions that were made in previous years but were not claimed as deductions.
- Available Contribution Room – The remaining room the client has to contribute without exceeding their RRSP limit.
Understanding Overcontributions
When reviewing the Notice of Assessment, pay attention to the available contribution room:
- If the number is positive, it indicates how much more the client can contribute safely.
- If the number is negative (shown in brackets), this indicates the client has overcontributed.
For example:
- A client has no deduction limit left for 2019.
- Their undeducted contributions from previous years were $2,973.
- Their available contribution room is therefore −$973.
This means the client has exceeded the limit by $973. Since the CRA allows a $2,000 buffer for overcontributions, this particular client is within the allowable limit and does not yet face penalties. However, if the negative amount exceeds $2,000, the excess is subject to a 1% per month penalty until corrected.
Steps to Take When Overcontributions Are Found
- Verify the Amount – Check the dates and amounts of contributions to see if any were made in the first 60 days of the following year, which can sometimes be applied to either year.
- Inform the Client – If the negative available contribution room indicates an overcontribution, discuss the situation with your client.
- Plan Next Steps – Depending on the client’s circumstances:
- They may deduct the contribution in the following year if they gain additional RRSP room.
- Or they may need to withdraw the excess amount to avoid penalty tax.
- Document Everything – Make a note of the overcontribution and your advice, as this is important for future tax planning and compliance.
Key Takeaways
- The Notice of Assessment is your primary reference for identifying RRSP overcontributions.
- A negative available contribution room signals a potential overcontribution.
- The CRA allows a $2,000 buffer, but amounts above that are penalized.
- Always review contribution dates and plan with the client to avoid unnecessary penalties.
By understanding where to find this information and how to interpret it, you can ensure your clients stay compliant with RRSP rules and avoid unnecessary tax costs.
Leave a Reply