Table of Contents
- Introduction to the Attribution Rules
- Where the Attribution Rules Will Not Apply
- Deducting Carrying Charges from Your Investment Income
- Deducting Interest Expense on Loans Used to Earn Investment Income
- How to Look Up the Marginal Tax Rate on Investment Income
Introduction to the Attribution Rules
When learning about Canadian income tax, one of the more advanced topics you may encounter is the attribution rules. These rules are designed to prevent certain strategies that could allow high-income taxpayers to shift income to family members in order to reduce their overall taxes. While the rules may not apply to everyday tax returns, they are important to understand, especially if you work with clients who have investments or high incomes.
What Are the Attribution Rules?
At their core, the attribution rules stop taxpayers from transferring investments or income to a family member in order to take advantage of that person’s lower tax rate. The government introduced these rules because, without them, people could significantly reduce their taxes through simple transfers of property, gifts, or loans to family members.
Here’s an example to make it simple:
- James is in the highest tax bracket in Ontario, paying a marginal rate of 54%.
- He earns $10,000 of interest income from his investments, meaning he would pay about $5,400 in tax.
- James thinks: “My 16-year-old daughter Melissa doesn’t have any income, so if I put these investments in her name, she would pay almost no tax, and I could keep the $10,000.”
Sounds good, right? But the CRA doesn’t allow this. Because Melissa is a minor and not dealing at arm’s length with James, the attribution rules kick in:
The $10,000 of interest income will still be taxed in James’ hands, even though the investments are in Melissa’s name.
Why Do the Rules Exist?
The CRA knows that high-income taxpayers could use family transfers to avoid paying their fair share of taxes. The attribution rules prevent this by applying to:
- Transfers to minor children (under age 18)
- Transfers to spouses or common-law partners
These rules apply whether the transfer is made by gift, sale, or loan.
What Happens in Practice
Thanks to the attribution rules:
- High-income individuals cannot shift income to minors to save taxes.
- Income earned from investments that are transferred to a spouse may also be attributed back to the original owner unless certain planning steps are followed.
- Attempts to use these strategies with minor children can also trigger tax on split income (TOSI), which further limits tax savings.
It’s important to note that these rules mostly affect tax planning for wealthy families or situations involving multiple properties and investments. For typical families preparing regular tax returns, the attribution rules rarely come into play.
Key Takeaways for Beginners
- The CRA prevents income shifting to minors: Any income earned from assets transferred to children under 18 is taxed to the parent.
- Spousal transfers may be attributed back: Special planning is required to transfer investment income to a spouse legitimately.
- Simple transfers to reduce taxes won’t work: Gifting investments to family members purely for tax savings is not allowed.
- Advanced planning may be needed for high-income clients: Only in situations involving family tax planning or large reorganizations do these rules require careful analysis.
Understanding the attribution rules is an important step in learning Canadian tax. Even if they won’t affect most clients you encounter, knowing the rules helps you recognize potential planning issues and ensures you give accurate guidance to families with investments or high incomes.
Where the Attribution Rules Will Not Apply
In the previous section, we discussed the attribution rules—how they prevent taxpayers from transferring investments or income to minors or spouses in order to reduce taxes. While these rules are strict, there are legitimate situations where income can be shifted without triggering attribution. It’s important to understand these exceptions, especially if you are helping clients with tax planning.
Legal Ways Around the Attribution Rules
The attribution rules primarily apply when:
- Income is shifted to a minor child under the age of 18, or
- Income is shifted to a spouse or common-law partner without proper arrangements.
However, there are cases where it is possible to transfer investments legitimately to a family member with a lower tax rate. Here’s how it works for spouses:
- Selling Investments at Fair Market Value:
- If a high-income spouse wants the lower-income spouse to report investment income, they must sell the investments to the spouse at fair market value.
- This is not a gift. The transaction must be at arm’s length with a proper sale price.
- Using a Loan Agreement:
- Often, the lower-income spouse may not have the cash to buy the investments outright. In this case, a loan agreement is used.
- The loan must include an interest rate, which is either the CRA prescribed rate or a standard commercial rate.
- Interest must be paid annually. The CRA requires the payment to be made within 30 days after year-end.
- Reporting Income Correctly:
- The lower-income spouse reports the investment income on their tax return.
- They can also deduct the interest paid on the loan, as this interest is considered a carrying charge to earn income.
- The higher-income spouse reports the interest received as income.
This process allows legitimate tax planning while avoiding the attribution rules.
Transfers to Adult Children
The attribution rules do not apply to children over the age of 18. This is because the government considers them legal adults, responsible for their own taxes. For example:
- If James wants to transfer an investment portfolio to his 20-year-old daughter, Melissa:
- He can gift the investments legitimately, and
- Melissa reports the investment income on her tax return at her own tax rate.
It’s important to note that even for adult children, the transfer must be legitimate, not just a scheme to avoid taxes.
Important Notes for Beginners
- Planning around attribution rules is rare in everyday tax preparation. It is usually relevant only for high-income clients or complex family tax planning.
- Transfers to minors should generally be avoided due to TOSI (Tax on Split Income) and other tax complexities.
- Always ensure proper documentation (loan agreements, interest payments, fair market value sales) if attempting to shift income legally.
Key Takeaways
- Spousal transfers can work with proper sale and loan agreements.
- Gifting to minors triggers attribution rules; avoid this for tax planning.
- Adult children (over 18) can receive gifts or investments legitimately, and report income themselves.
- Legitimate documentation is critical to ensure compliance with CRA rules.
While the attribution rules may seem complicated, knowing where they do not apply helps you provide accurate guidance and prevents costly mistakes. For most typical tax returns, these situations are uncommon, but for larger portfolios or high-income families, they are worth understanding.
Deducting Carrying Charges from Your Investment Income
When you invest, there are often costs involved in managing and maintaining your investments. In Canadian tax law, some of these costs can be deducted from your investment income. These costs are referred to as carrying charges. Understanding what counts as a carrying charge and what does not can help you legally reduce the amount of tax you pay on your investment income.
What Are Carrying Charges?
Carrying charges are essentially expenses you incur to earn investment income. If you pay money to manage, maintain, or protect your investments, those expenses may qualify as carrying charges and be deductible on your tax return.
Some common examples of carrying charges include:
- Management Fees
- Fees paid to financial advisors, portfolio managers, or investment counselors.
- These fees are deductible only for non-registered accounts.
- Fees related to RRSPs or TFSAs are not deductible, because the investment income in those accounts is tax-sheltered.
- Accounting Fees
- Only accounting fees related to tracking and reporting investment income can be deducted.
- Fees for general tax preparation, personal finances, or unrelated business activities are not deductible.
- For example, if you paid an accountant $300 to prepare your tax return but they separate $50 of their time for managing your investment records, you can deduct that $50.
What Is Not Deductible
Not all expenses connected to investments can be claimed. Here are some common examples of non-deductible costs:
- Commissions on buying or selling stocks: These are accounted for in the Adjusted Cost Base (ACB) and capital gains calculations, not as carrying charges.
- Safety deposit box fees: No longer deductible for 2014 and later tax years. (They were deductible for years before 2014.)
- Newsletters, newspapers, and magazines related to investments: Usually considered personal in nature and are often disallowed by the CRA.
Why It Matters
Deducting legitimate carrying charges reduces the taxable portion of your investment income. This means less tax owed at the end of the year. But it’s important to keep proper documentation, including invoices and statements, to prove that the expense was directly related to earning investment income.
Key Takeaways for Beginners
- Deductible carrying charges must be directly related to producing investment income.
- Non-registered accounts allow deduction of management fees; RRSPs and TFSAs do not.
- Accounting fees are deductible only if they relate to tracking investment income.
- Commissions and transaction costs are not deductible here—they are handled in capital gains calculations.
- Small investment-related costs like newsletters or personal subscriptions are usually not worth claiming, as CRA often disallows them.
Understanding carrying charges is an important step in making sure you get all the deductions you’re entitled to when reporting investment income. The next step is learning about interest expenses on loans used to produce investment income, which is another type of deductible expense you should be aware of.
Deducting Interest Expense on Loans Used to Earn Investment Income
When investing, many Canadians use borrowed money to grow their portfolios. The interest paid on these loans can sometimes be deducted from your taxable income, but only under certain conditions. Understanding the rules around interest deductions is an important part of preparing investment-related tax returns.
What Is Interest Expense in This Context?
Interest expense in tax terms is the interest paid on a loan that was borrowed to earn investment income. This could include interest on loans used to buy stocks, bonds, or other income-producing investments.
For example:
- Suppose you borrow $100,000 from your broker to invest in dividend-paying stocks.
- During the year, the loan accrues $3,000 in interest.
- The investment generates $5,000 in dividends.
The $3,000 you paid in interest is deductible on your tax return, reducing the amount of taxable income from your investment.
Key Rules for Deductibility
- Non-Registered Accounts Only
- Interest paid on loans for non-registered investment accounts is deductible.
- Interest on loans for RRSPs or TFSAs is not deductible because the income in these accounts is tax-sheltered.
- Interest Related to Business or Rental Property
- If a loan is used for business purposes or to purchase a rental property, the interest is not reported as a carrying charge.
- Instead, it’s recorded in the appropriate statement:
- Rental property mortgage interest: Reported on T776 (Statement of Rental Income).
- Business loan interest: Reported on T2125 (Statement of Business Activities).
- Investment Type Does Not Have to Generate Immediate Income
- Even if the investment doesn’t produce dividends or interest in the current year (e.g., growth stocks), the interest on the loan can still be deductible.
- Courts have ruled that as long as the securities are capable of generating dividends or interest in the future, the interest expense qualifies.
- Capital Gains Consideration
- Technically, capital gains are not considered income under the Income Tax Act.
- However, if the investment is capable of generating future dividend or interest income, the interest remains deductible, even if the primary goal is capital appreciation.
How It Works in Practice
Returning to our example:
- You borrow $100,000 to buy dividend stocks.
- Dividend income: $5,000
- Interest on loan: $3,000
On your tax return:
- You report the $5,000 dividend income.
- You deduct the $3,000 interest expense on Schedule 4, reducing the taxable portion of your investment income.
This lowers the tax you owe, making borrowing for investment purposes more tax-efficient—as long as you follow the rules above.
Important Takeaways
- Only loans used for non-registered accounts are eligible for interest deduction.
- Loans for RRSPs or TFSAs are not deductible.
- Business and rental property loans are reported separately in their respective statements.
- Interest on loans for growth stocks or other income-capable investments is generally deductible, even if no income is earned yet.
Understanding these rules can help you maximize deductions and reduce your tax liability on investment income. Interest deductions are a powerful tool, but proper documentation and careful adherence to CRA rules are essential.
How to Look Up the Marginal Tax Rate on Investment Income
When preparing or reviewing a client’s tax return, one common question is: “How much tax will I pay on my investment income?” Investment income comes in several forms—interest income, dividends (eligible and non-eligible), and capital gains—and each type is taxed differently. Understanding the marginal tax rate for each type of investment income is key to answering this question.
What Is a Marginal Tax Rate?
The marginal tax rate is the rate of tax that applies to the next dollar of income a taxpayer earns. For investment income, this determines how much tax a client will pay on additional interest, dividends, or capital gains.
- Interest income: Taxed at the full marginal tax rate.
- Capital gains: Only 50% of capital gains are taxable, so the effective tax rate is half the marginal rate.
- Eligible dividends: Receive a preferential tax rate through the dividend gross-up and dividend tax credit.
- Ineligible dividends: Taxed at a higher rate than eligible dividends but still lower than regular interest income in some cases.
How to Determine the Marginal Tax Rate
To find the marginal tax rate on a client’s investment income, you need two pieces of information:
- Taxable income of the client.
- Province of residence, because each province has its own tax brackets.
Once you know these, you can use a reliable online marginal tax rate calculator. These tools allow you to input income levels and province, and they will provide:
- Marginal tax rate on interest income.
- Marginal tax rate on capital gains.
- Marginal tax rate on eligible and non-eligible dividends.
For example:
- A taxpayer in Ontario with $75,000 of taxable income:
- Marginal tax rate on interest: 29.65%
- Marginal tax rate on capital gains: 14.83% (50% of 29.65%)
- Marginal tax rate on eligible dividends: much lower than interest
- Marginal tax rate on ineligible dividends: higher than eligible dividends
- A high-income taxpayer earning $350,000 in Ontario:
- Top marginal rate on interest: 53.53%
- Capital gains rate: 26.77%
- Eligible dividends: significantly lower than ineligible dividends
Why This Matters for Tax Planning
Knowing the marginal tax rate helps in multiple scenarios:
- Estimating tax liability on new investment income: For instance, if a client plans to earn $10,000 in interest or dividends, you can estimate the tax they will pay.
- Capital gains planning: If a client sells a property or other investments, you can calculate the tax on the taxable portion of the gain.
- Income splitting considerations: Helps determine the tax impact if income is being shifted between family members (while respecting attribution rules).
Tips for Beginners
- Always confirm the client’s province of residence, as provincial tax rates vary.
- Remember that capital gains are taxed at 50%, so their effective rate is lower than interest.
- Eligible dividends always receive a favorable tax treatment, making them more tax-efficient than ineligible dividends or interest.
- Use up-to-date tax calculators online; rates change each year.
Understanding marginal tax rates is one of the most useful skills for a tax preparer, especially when discussing investment income with clients. With this knowledge, you can provide clear guidance on the tax impact of interest, dividends, and capital gains without needing to rely on specific tax software.
Leave a Reply